When you read something, you assume that the author has written it in good faith. That their intentions are truthful and honest; that they want to invite you into a shared understanding of the truth.
Of course, we also know that plenty writers lie. But what if they lie to bring you closer to the truth?
What if they tell you they’re lying?
Freewrite
For this prompt, I want to guide you through the complexities of lying versus truth telling.
For now, make a list of lies that feel like the truth.
What are some things that you know to be untrue, but feel like they’re true nonetheless? Conspiracy theories, for example, have this quality: we have all of this evidence that people landed on the moon, but the conspiracy that it was manufactured by a government hellbent on winning the Cold War nonetheless feels plausible.
Personal truths can also have this quality. You might know, for example, that humans don’t have psychic powers—but nonetheless believe you can hone some kind of emergent ability to control the direction of the wind.
That’s an extreme idea, but the gist is that we have personal truths that sit in competition with more universal ones.
Make a list of those. Ask yourself where and how truth and reality seem to diverge for you.
Note: the following poem is a bit NSFW.
Poem: “Smear in the Shape of a Crescent Moon // (Un)faithful Poem Containing White Lies Purely for the Sake of Narrative” by Reuben Gelley Newman
Retrieved from his phenomenal collection Dear Dear.
with Lorde and Vivaldi
The acid residue
of burnout like coffee left
in a thermos for three days. Wondering
if your boyfriend gave your necklaces
back when you left them, longingly,
at his place. Remembering that both you
and he forgot them. You forget your keys
today, you’ll have to ask the neighbor to buzz
you into your apartment. What’d it be like
to buzz out of the beat of life for a minute,
to elide the algo rhythm. Instagram brings you
reels of bassoonists, all the jokes about the word
when translated into German. You play Vivaldi’s
Fagottkonzerte, you exalt faggotry and frolicking.
One summer you streamed Melodrama
on repeat, wanting to seem hip;
come this fall you’ve still only played brat
once through. One hookup
asks you to clutch at his
nipples while you tongue
the tip of his dick. You use
a condom with another, and he says
you should get on PrEP so he can breed you.
The associative poem breeds complacency,
line breaks that don’t cohere, a narrative that feels
unfinished. Vivaldi reminds you of your grandfather,
but maybe it’s just this time of year: seasonal
depression, marcato as the bassoon trickles
down the melody, a tickle in your throat.
You send bassoon memes to your crush.
You add Spotify songs to your stories,
and only occasionally promote Bandcamp;
your Spotify Wrapped smirks nerdily
at all the gays with their Taylor
and their Charli xcx. Good boy,
the top says during sex, but you want
to be good, morally speaking.
The poem should end with some epiphany
about goodness. Your crush tells you not
to use plastic utensils, but that feels so small
compared to our country banning books, funding
bombs. You read The Work of Art in the Age
of Mechanical Reproduction and take a nude
in the airplane bathroom, then don’t
share it to your alt, which is followed mostly
by bots. Your boyfriend shares a meme
about Daniel Craig in Queer. Your crush
shares a meme about smiling
during a kiss.
Divinations
I love this poem. It’s polyvocal, associative, frenetic; it works within different registers and juxtaposes incredibly unalike experiences. Most importantly, as acknowledged in the title: the speaker is lying to us.
More specifically, the speaker has included “white lies purely for the sake of narrative.”
Where are the lies? It’s tempting to ask that question; it is far more noteworthy that the lies cannot be readily discerned. (I know Reuben personally, and I can’t identify with 100% confidence all of the parts of the poem that aren’t truthful.)
What matters is that this poem arrives at something truthful, even if events in the poem may not have transpired. This is the distinction between Truth and sincerity that Louise Glück makes in her essay “Against Sincerity,” which I’ll expand upon in a bit.
To catalog some of this poem’s registers, we have:
- Queer longing
- Vivaldi
- Contemporary music
- Gay hookup culture
- Walter Benjamin
- Bots, memes, Spotify, and internet culture
The result is not only an assemblage of experiences that hardly cohere; it’s a particular feeling of being alive, right now. One friend described this poem to me as “what it’s like to scroll on Instagram.” Which feels accurate: we’re pummeled with a bunch of images and ideas that associatively become a narrative, but actually have little to do with one another, other than our personalized algorithms. (See Reuben: “to elide the algo rhythm.”)
The poem also has a sense of reaching out without reciprocation, of looking for something or someone stable to hang meaning off of, and never quite finding that person or thing. “The poem should end with some epiphany / about goodness,” the speaker says, but the poem doesn’t. Is that what the speaker is looking for? Is that what the poem needs to make sense?
But the poem does make sense, at least to me. Or it doesn’t, and that’s the point. I feel, here, the angst of being alive right now. The world is too complicated to know and the common work of knowing the world grows further out of reach; information moves too fast, our minds never experience deep rest, and life is always a bit too liquid for me to hang meaning off of it. This poem’s polyvocalness arrives at that same feeling, in images sometimes gorgeous, sometimes unsettling, but always true—even if the speaker is lying.
Against Sincerity
This section is retrieved from an essay I wrote a couple of years ago on the same topic.
You can find a PDF of this essay here.
“Against Sincerity” is an essay I encourage every serious poet to read. The title is provocative (perhaps iconoclastic), but the essay isn’t saying poets shouldn’t be sincere; rather, it’s pushing back on the notion that a poem needs to stick to the facts in order to be authentic. The “truth” can be accessed without having to dutifully transcribe reality.
Glück, the 2020 Nobel Prize winner in Literature, helpfully differentiates three terms that are often used interchangeably, but perhaps shouldn’t be:
- Actuality: “The world of event.”
- In other words: Things as they actually happened in the real world.
- Truth: “The embodied vision, illumination, or enduring discovery which is the ideal of art.”
- In other words: The deeper realities which art reveals.
- Honesty or sincerity: “‘telling the truth,’ which is not necessarily the path to illumination.”
- In other words: The desire to stick closely to “actuality” in one’s art.
These distinctions might seem a bit arbitrary or opaque, but they yield important insights into the nature of art versus reality. One bit of irony I love to tell poets is this: you might have to lie to tell the truth.
Art, including poetry, is, above all else, a distortion of reality. We’re not trying to convey every fact or detail or experience; to do so would be overwhelming and, quite frankly, boring. (An exception might be certain works of Modernism, such as Joyce’s Ulysses. Certainly not a boring work of literature, but it is rather dense and impenetrable in its efforts to convey life as it actually occurs.)
Rather, the artist or poet creates art by selecting, juxtaposing, and heightening or minimizing certain details. A photographer does this by changing lenses and editing colors; a musician does this by adding instruments or altering sounds or using autotune. A poet has the many tools of craft at their disposal.
So, the goal isn’t to convey life in excruciating detail, but rather to achieve a radical authenticity in the work. The poet should use whatever means necessary to do so.
This is not to say that you should deceive your reader. In fact, readers can usually tell when they’re being lied to. The goal is, above all, authenticity, which is something like a north star of poetry writing: follow it, and you’ll probably get to where you’re trying to go.
Prompt: Lying to Your Reader
Write a poem that lies at least once to the reader—in order to better tell the truth of something. You can use, if you’d like, the truth distortions in your freewrite as a doorway into this poem. You can also try writing in persona, which is innately a form of lying (or at the very least, fiction).
Arrive an emotional or greater truth even if you have to lie to get there.





Leave a Reply